?

Log in

No account? Create an account
 

connecting things. or another "duh" moment perhaps? - silver Harloe

About connecting things. or another "duh" moment perhaps?

Previous Entry connecting things. or another "duh" moment perhaps? Sep. 29th, 2007 @ 08:31 am Next Entry
last night I watched a movie about world war II and I was thinking about how it's usually innocent kids that suffer from war. whether because their families get killed, or because half of them, seeking little more than a means to live, got stuck on the wrong side.

as usual my thoughts turned to my own lack of military experience and I once again pondered joining the army (which now accepts people up to 5 years older than I am). I thought of my failure to serve my country. admittedly, it's a country which I now very much disagree with -- as we become more religious and more tied to control of people and more and more trade away rights for "security"... but then I think about something Heinlein wrote which until this morning I very much believed.

Heinlein, in at least one of his future societies, had this idea that military service earns you the right to vote. I often thought of it when I felt guilty about our country. I thought, "well, who am I to decide, who was unwilling to lay my life on the line for these principles?" that was Heinlein's point - that people unwilling to sacrifice for their future should have no say in other people's futures. I thought I had to serve my time to have the right to decide. I've often chided our leaders for dodging military experience, and when I think about joining politics, I often think about how my own failure to have any would work against me (and I thought rightfully so)...

so, yah, I used to think he was right, but this morning I thought of another thing that once touched my life. there was a PBS series in the 80's called "War" by a historian named Gwen Dyer. the thing that stuck with me in remembering that series was always the chapter "Anyone's Son Will Do" about how the military has taken thousands of years of experience to become freaking amazing at mind control. a modern boot camp will turn anyone into a soldier - save only those the military themselves choose to reject (a class which shrinks in times of war, of course).

so then I connected them, finally, and realized that Heinlein's society would be controlled by people whose very purpose was to be controlled by others -- in essence, a couple generals would decide all elections. great as long as they're the benevolent dictators chosen despite their resistance to leadership... but that's not who our generals are. our generals have their agenda, too, and it's mostly about keeping the military in power.

the thoughts are still mixing around in my head, so I'm not sure where I'll end up. certainly, if everyone in the military were one of Clancy's heroes, we'd be lucky to be led by them. but many of them are just drones, who'd be equally comfortable in Hitler's armies as our own. though I can't really fault them for it, I can't really say "oh, they alone have the right to lead us", either...

mixing. mixing. it's so hard to balance the contradictions when various childhood heroes and experiences turn out to collide. okay, enough rambling.
Leave a comment
From:(Anonymous)
Date:October 4th, 2007 11:27 am (UTC)

Gwen Dyer

(Link)
I saw "War" on PBS too. I have the book but I'd love to know where to find the video/s. The series so upset William Buckley that he even ridiculed Dyers' leather jacket in a column.
[User Picture Icon]
From:aldirmazlik
Date:October 4th, 2007 05:21 pm (UTC)
(Link)
For a while I have been wondering about the value of having mandatory military service for all citizens of 2 years. Thinking that that would likely increase the level of concern the average person would have for how we as a country act and react to things. Also would help the highly individualistic nature promoted be reminded about being part of a group and the value of group over individual. Interesting thoughts/ideas to batter around.. though anything of this nature would require a vastly different military (one where women were not in danger of sexual abuse, not to mention the dont ask dont tell crap)
(Leave a comment)
Top of Page Powered by LiveJournal.com